You are not logged in

LoginRegister

Log in

FinePix X100

Twitter

Follow

MFP Facebook

FujiShop

Fujifilm digital cameras, accessories, memory cards all sold direct from Fujifilm UK

Get involved!

Street photography your views

Do you approve or not?

Have you got the bottle? Do you think it's intrusive and too personal?

How would you feel if you found yourself on Flickr in a "street" shot?

 

1 person likes this.

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 14:48
Comment

My opinion is here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/nickodim/sets/72157630096403410/

I'm all for it. People get too tight nowadays about their personal space... It's all becoming really stupid, what's the point in uploading all your photoes on FB and making them available and then ranting about someone taking a shot of you in public... Hope I make sense here... It's all a bit messed up. It may be a bit on the edge of the "moral law" but nevertheless it's fun, it's exciting, it makes sense shooting life on the streets, so why not? 

P.S. I'd love to end up in someone's flickr page on a nice street shot. 

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 15:50
Comment

I totally agree with McNicko. The world and his wife and all the kids have their photos on Facebook now, so why worry. I love candid shots, personally.

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 16:09
Comment

 

I had my photo taken once, it was used as a advert for body building and made centerfold in Health and Efficiency with the caption, "You to could look like this, if your not careful"

http://www.flickr.com/photos/72386756@N00/

September Competition Entry http://www.myfinepix.co.uk/competition/entry/535652

Come with me and you'll be in a world of pure imagination

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 16:14
Comment

Difficult question....

I do a lot of street shots. The legal situation i somewhat like this (here in Germany): If you are part of a crowd or a not-substantial part of a photo (whatever this may be) you have no right to object. If you show your approval of being papped (waving, smiling, posing in any form) you cannot complain later. Not 100% firm law but more and more accepted - if you take part in a parade, procession, carnival...  even portraits of you can be taken.

The question is difficult because even within these rules there are many situations in which people would not like to see their photo taken. The golden rule is not a perfect but acceptable guideline for me - i never take photos from others in situations in which i would not accept being photographed by others.

I just came home from a musical parade. I took 650 photos (yeah!!) all with people on them. If i had asked for permission and some written confirmation that they had no objections i would have managed perhaps 5 photos and they would look just arranged.


 

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 16:20
Comment

I'm too ugly to worry about whether my face ends up on flickr or not Smile

Unfortunately it still has Smile

I like photography so can hardly complain .

The complications are only if you try to sell the images. That could get tricky nowadays without release forms .

I do most of my versions of those shots at events though rather than towns unless the events are in the towns.

I also think there is a bit of a moral dilemma . Would I upload a photograph of a person who has obvious distress or a possibly compromising shot ?

Probably not .

Would I if there was nothing I could do to prevent the outcome like a crashing plane or a sinking boat ? Yes , if only for the relevant authorities to look over as long as if I had first tried to help.

( Iknow that's not street photography but just giving an easy analogy )

Would I mind someone else doing that ?

Maybe not but I query their integrity simply because I would not be sharing similar values.

I think the main thing is if someone asked if would I mind not taking a photo of them I would oblige .

 

My Tutorials

 

My Blogs. 

&

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 16:56
Comment

Like you, myself and my partner have just come back from a festival today (World Pride 2012) and between us we have 100's & 100's of images as well, many of them "street" type shots as we were more interested in the people watching as opposed to the participants.

Hi Steve,

i would have no problem using these photos. Who goes to a Pride Parade (participant or visitor) knows that lots of photos will be taken there. Have a look at one of my blogs http://www.myfinepix.co.uk/blog/125333/335680 with photos from such an event. Do you think any of the people in these photos would object?

The description of the legal situation is just there because many people feel insecure about this side of the situation. I'm with you - for me too it more a moral (or social) question but with the points i've made i get along quite well.

In the meantime i had a first glance at my photos from today :)   

A bit strange but dam* good! 160 selected for editing! Yippie - can we have a few cold and rainy days please?

Show me yours - I'll show you mine Wink


 

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 16:57
Comment

With cameras watching our every move how can anyone complain about the occasional snap being taken.

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 17:28
Comment

They clearly had no problems with ending on a photo of a total stranger Wink

I think i will do a blog again. Hope Fuji solves the problems with blogs until then Innocent


 

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 17:33
Comment

If the people or person is incidental to the shot - i.e. not the main focus, I don't see anything wrong with it. After all, they are there to be seen by anyone who happens to be looking! If they are to be the focus of the shot, it would seem reasonable to me to ask if they mind - I have done this for several publicity photographs for our town. No-one has ever objected, although some ask why I am taking the picture. Being told they are there to make the library look useful seems to be accepted as reasonable, for instance!

George

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 18:15
Comment

.

The site maintenance bug hit again Sad

 


 

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 18:12
Comment

It is the Schlagermove Hamburg 2012    http://www.schlagermove.de/index.php?id=aftermove-party

Something very weird and can only be understood when you are German and drunk Wink

It's sort of a revival of 60th and 70th German text pop songs (which were terrible during their time and are even worse today). But lots of younger people have adopted these songs and use them for some time travel to something with a few hippy elements and very strange cloths.

http://www.schlagermovebilder.de/     <-- mine are better of course Wink


 

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 18:15
Comment

.

The site maintenance bug hit again Sad


 

Reply to comment

Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 19:26
Comment

I have no problem with candid shots but once I was out with my camera and a woman I didn't know just came up to me and asked if I would take photos of her kids playing on the swings , I flatly refused put my camera away and moved on 

kevc

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 19:38
Comment

Have no problem with photographing strangers morally but i only have the nerve to take them candidly-ish.

Although i would never take them if kids are in the shot, it upsets people and i fully understand why.

Gif 

Comp

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 20:21
Comment

I am a big fan of street work - in fact it comprises a very large part of the stuff I take.  I find it strange that many complain so, when they are under surveillence ( particularly in the UK) every moment they are outside the house!

Fact is, the law allows for it and if one works within the law, then so be it.  If I found myself in someone elses image, as long as they had acted within the law, I was in a public place and they  had not invaded my private space to get the image, I would accept that.

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 20:17
Comment

well i did do a blog on people watching on here couple of months ago with mixed comments. i would never photo a child as i think that could cause trouble, i also dont think taking snaps of people living on the streets is a fair thing to do.

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 21:39
Comment

I think it is very sad that we can no longer take pictures of small children - they are such natural poseurs! I don't particularly like children - they make far too much noise - but they do make very charming pictures.

George

Reply to comment

Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 21:43
Comment

I would not mind if I was caught on a photo and plastered all over the net with regard taking photos of the general public in everyday life I would have no problem with that like Nigel said he did a blog not long ago and very interesting it was. 

Reply to comment


Date Sat, 07/07/2012 - 23:11
Comment

I like street photo, I do a lot too and I don't care about intrusion (and also about law). But here in Marseille, it's a bit dangerous to take photos in some places, I've been already agressed for that, so I must be very careful if I do again, not about me but about the camera... not always easy...

In spite of my rage, I'm still a rat in a cage..

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 06:34
Comment

Someone mentioned kids - never liked taking child photos. Nothing to do with the law or the moral or anything I just don't like shots of children.

The people living on the street - well they are part of life, street photography is documenting life, so I see nothing wrong here if done in a reasonable way.

Candid is what makes things unique in street photography. And as much as I love shooting from a close distance I had to get a telephoto. People here in Bulgaria are a bit weird about these kind of things. If the camera is larger than a mobile phone - you're a reporter or something. Snap a lenshood on and things get worse. People here don't like journalists, not sure why but they freak out when they see one. So - telephoto is the way for candid here, nothing below 80mm(FF size that is)

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 08:04
Comment

I seem to be drifting more and more in so a combination of street portrait.  I love catching peoples expressions. (new lense on wish list)

 

Candid is good, as is the less candid.

 

Regarding people being hurt or injured - no I can't see me taking those, but if I was around when a major incident took place, I'd have no problems taking some pictures - but more of the event and the aftermath, not the victims (hope that makes sense)

 

Someone mentioned picrures of people living on the street. I'd love to have the bottle to do it, but I thik to take effective imagages you really have to be accepted and trusted by the poeple in the area that you're taking the pictures.

 

I'm still very much a beginner in this, but it's a wonderful source of subject matter.

Yesterday is History, Tomorrow is a Mystery, Today is a Gift

My abstract comp entry

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 08:22
Comment

I am quite a fan of "candid" street shots.  Last Sunday we were in Chester and I captured this chap (don't know who he is).  It just got me thinking about what other folk are thinking as they go about their daily task.  It seems that candid work can provide some good photos rather than those posed (false) shots.

                        

Cheers  (Oh yes,  if I found a shot of myself on Facebook or elswhere, it would not bother me whatsoever.  As long as they got my best side!!! Lol

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 09:05
Comment

taking shots of people that are clearly down on there luck for what ever reason i think should not happen. it is nothing to do with bottle as a lot of the people on here with a bridge camera could take a half decent one from a distance. after this months theme was annouced weeks ago i saw a homeless person sat with a begging note asking for money just sitting there not speaking. i am sad to say the thought of a good shot and winning this comp went straight thru my mind then i thought should i offer him a fiver to pose but i resisted went back and just gave him a couple of quid, before snapping these scenes you not to try and put yourself in there posistion. who knows

there are a couple of shots likes these in this months comp they tell a sad story of life on the streets fit the theme but personnaly i dont like them.

candid shots like the one steve posted are fine with me i do those when i see nothing else to snap away at.

if anyone wants to see my people watching blog here is the link

 http://www.myfinepix.co.uk/blog/138/459886

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 11:32
Comment

Street photography is almost a duty.  To not record the down/upside of any society is little less than condoning it.  It is the duty of photographers to ensure that the truth is recorded and presented.

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 09:40
Comment

Along the lines of what Paul has said, life is not all smiles.  This chap in York,.... I wonder how he deals with day-to-day activities that we take for granted.

           

There for the grace etc etc.

 

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 09:51
Comment

 

I have got to wholeheartedly agree with Paul on this one. Due to photographers of yore who have blessed us with their foresight, artistic expression to record the life and times of our predecessors. We can see poverty, family pride and character lined faces of hard working people. That enables us to conjure up our imaginations and makes me for one appreciate for what we have. I can see the fear on a Tommy's face as he goes over the top. I can see a work weary miner coming off shift, children at play in quaint outfits and ladies who took pride in their appearance. So I'll go about my hobby with a free spirit and I'm not going to worry about what others think or by what might never happen. It'll stunt my growth.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/72386756@N00/

September Competition Entry http://www.myfinepix.co.uk/competition/entry/535652

Come with me and you'll be in a world of pure imagination

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 10:31
Comment

I recently went to Ireland for a holiday - and just liked this shot of three locals watching the world go by - would this be deemed acceptable - its such a shame - but I try to respect people when taking shots in crowed areas.............

Every day is a new beginning enjoy yours............

 and if you can or even want to - be polite, respectful and helpful in your comments...........be clear - nuances of speech and facial expressions cannot come over in writing

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 10:43
Comment

 

Jean, not only is that acceptable but a shot from the front would have been better.

Paul, you've got it spot on mate. Street photography is recording life as it happens. I haven't done any myself yet but I do plan to. I would love to be able to get on the streets and take photos of the homeless and destitute. Does that sound bad? Maybe it does but they are the faces that make up some of our city streets and, to put it bluntly, they make better photos than shoppers with M&S bags. Would I stick my camera in their face, no way, with todays cameras there is no need. If I saw a face I'd like to capture I hope I'd have the nerve to ask if needed.

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 11:03
Comment

I have recently started taking more and more 'street photography' shots, and agree with a lot of the previous points regarding what should / shouldn't be taken.

I think though, that certain subject matters shouldn't just be a 'yes' or a 'no' as to whether you take them. I have no problem with taking photos of children, for example, but only because I now that I am not doing it for the wrong reasons.

One of my favourites that I have taken was at a out of town shopping village type thing in Somerset where a man was sitting outside a shop with his daughter waiting for his wife. Just as I took the photo, the daughter went to kiss her Dad. It was a lucky shot.............

 

Circles     Fly     Greylag

Reply to comment


Date Sun, 08/07/2012 - 11:14
Comment

I think there's also much to be said about the historical perspective of photography.

 

Not too many years ago, the people in this picture would have been dismissed from thier jobs. I, for one, am glad that they are still there, and admire the bravery of people that take on the political issues at a street level.

 

Even now, these individuals face the possibility of disciplinary action - unfairly I might add.

 

 

 

 

Yesterday is History, Tomorrow is a Mystery, Today is a Gift

My abstract comp entry